What is deflation? The only guide you need to read

Imagine walking into your favourite store and finding everything 10% cheaper than last month. Sounds great, right? But what if your salary also dropped by 15%, and your home's value plummeted by 20%? Welcome to the complex world of deflation – an economic phenomenon that turns the simple act of waiting to make a purchase into a nationwide economic strategy, and not in a good way.

While we often worry about prices going up, deflation shows us why prices going down can be just as threatening to our economic well-being. In this guide, we'll uncover why some lose sleep over falling prices, explore real-world examples that have shaped nations, and understand why a healthy economy is all about finding the right balance.

What is deflation?

Deflation is when prices of goods and services decrease across the economy over time. It's essentially the opposite of inflation, which is what we're more familiar with (when prices going up year after year).

To put it simply: if inflation means your dollar buys less tomorrow than it does today, deflation means your dollar will buy more tomorrow than it does today.

Imagine walking into your local grocery store and noticing that milk costs $3.50 this month, down from $3.75 last month. Then next month, it drops to $3.25. If this pattern happens across many products and services throughout the economy, that's deflation in action.

Is deflation good or bad?

It's tempting to think deflation is great news (spending less on groceries does sound like the dream). Unfortunately, the reality is more complicated.

The good side:

• Your purchasing power increases
• Your savings are worth more without doing anything
• Essential goods become more affordable

The not-so-good side:

• People delay purchases (why buy today if it'll be cheaper tomorrow?)
• Businesses earn less revenue, leading to potential layoffs
• Debt becomes more burdensome (you owe the same amount, but money is worth more)

The biggest danger is what economists call the "deflationary spiral." This is when falling prices lead to lower production, which causes job losses, which reduces spending power, which pushes prices down further... and the cycle continues downward.

What causes deflation?

Deflation doesn't just happen randomly. There are several key triggers:

1. Contraction in money supply

When there's less money circulating in the economy relative to the goods and services available, prices tend to fall. This can happen when central banks tighten monetary policy or when credit markets freeze up during financial crises.

2. Decreased consumer demand

When people spend less, whether due to economic uncertainty, rising unemployment, or shifting preferences, businesses often respond by lowering prices to attract customers.

3. Increased productivity or efficiency

Sometimes deflation happens for positive reasons. When companies find ways to produce more goods with fewer resources (like through technological innovation), they can pass those savings on as lower prices. Yes, for profit-hungry companies - this is rare, but it’s still possible. 

4. Government and central bank policies

Certain fiscal and monetary decisions can inadvertently trigger deflation, especially if they're too restrictive during economic downturns.

How is deflation measured?

Just like inflation, deflation is typically measured using price indexes, with the Consumer Price Index (CPI) being the most common. When the CPI shows a negative percentage change over time, that's deflation.

It's important to distinguish between:

• Deflation: A general decrease in prices (negative inflation rate)
• Disinflation: When inflation slows down but prices are still rising, just at a slower rate
• Inflation: A general increase in prices over time

Economists look at various sub-indexes too, as deflation might affect different sectors differently. For example, technology products have experienced their own form of deflation for decades, even during periods of overall inflation.

What are the effects of deflation?

Short-term benefits for consumers

In the immediate term, consumers might celebrate as their money stretches further. Essential goods cost less, and savings seem to grow in value automatically.

Long-term consequences

The longer-term picture is where things get problematic:

• Delayed purchases: Consumers postpone buying non-essential items, expecting even lower prices in the future.
• Business challenges: Companies face declining revenues while many of their costs remain fixed.
• Job market impact: As businesses struggle with reduced profits, layoffs often follow, increasing unemployment.
• Wage deflation: Eventually, wages start to decrease too, offsetting any benefit from lower prices.

The deflationary spiral explained

The most feared consequence is the deflationary spiral:

1. Prices fall
2. Consumption decreases (as people wait for even lower prices)
3. Production cuts follow
4. Unemployment rises
5. Less money is spent in the economy
6. Prices fall further
7. Repeat

This vicious cycle is what turned the 1929 stock market crash into the Great Depression, which is why central banks are typically quick to fight even hints of deflation.

Why deflation makes debt worse

One of deflation's cruellest effects is on debt. Here's why:

When prices and potentially wages fall, but your debt stays the same, the real burden of that debt actually increases. Imagine you have a $250,000 mortgage:

• During inflation: Your income likely rises over time, making that fixed payment feel smaller in proportion to your earnings.
• During deflation: Your income might decrease, but your mortgage payment remains unchanged, taking a bigger bite out of your budget.

Plus, the value of the asset you purchased (like a house) might decrease during deflation, potentially leading to negative equity (owing more than the asset is worth).

This debt burden effect can ripple through the economy, leading to increased defaults, foreclosures, and bankruptcies.

How does deflation affect the economy?

The broader economic impacts of deflation can be severe:

Recession and depression risks

Extended periods of deflation are strongly associated with economic contractions. The most famous example is the Great Depression, when U.S. prices fell by roughly 25% between 1929 and 1933.

Reduced business investment

When companies expect falling prices and revenues, they're less likely to invest in new projects, equipment, or employees. Why expand when you expect smaller returns?

Central bank challenges

Fighting deflation can be harder than fighting inflation. While central banks can always raise interest rates to combat inflation, there's a limit to how far they can cut rates to fight deflation (known as the "zero lower bound" problem).

Banking system stress

As borrowers struggle with the increasing real value of their debts, loan defaults rise, potentially threatening financial stability.

Can deflation ever be a good thing?

Yes, in certain contexts, deflation isn't necessarily bad:

Technological deflation

The consistent price drops in electronics like TVs, computers, and smartphones represent a form of "good deflation." These price decreases stem from innovation and efficiency gains, not economic distress.

Sector-specific benefits

Some industries might benefit from deflation in their input costs. For example, manufacturing businesses might enjoy lower raw material prices even if it creates challenges elsewhere.

Short-term vs. structural deflation

Brief episodes of mild deflation don't always spell disaster. It's the persistent, economy-wide deflation that raises red flags for economists.

The key difference is the cause: deflation from increased productivity and technological advancement is generally positive, while deflation from collapsed demand is problematic.

How do governments and central banks fight deflation?

When deflation threatens, policymakers have several tools at their disposal:

Monetary policy tools

• Lowering interest rates: Making borrowing cheaper to encourage spending and investment
• Quantitative Easing (QE): Central banks purchase assets like government bonds to increase money supply
• Forward Guidance: Promising to keep policies accommodative for extended periods to build confidence

Fiscal policy approaches

• Government spending: Increased public expenditure on infrastructure and services
• Tax cuts: Reducing tax burdens to boost consumer spending power
• Direct payments: Stimulus checks or universal basic income proposals

What happens to investments during deflation?

Different asset classes perform very differently during deflationary periods:

Cash and high-quality bonds

Cash and government bonds often perform well during deflation because their fixed returns become more valuable as prices fall. However, if deflation leads to a severe economic crisis, even government bonds could face risks.

Stocks and real estate

Equities and property typically struggle during deflation because:

• Corporate profits decline as prices fall
• Real estate values drop while mortgage debt remains unchanged
• Dividend payments may be reduced as companies conserve cash

Defensive investment strategies

Some approaches that might help protect portfolios include:

• Focus on companies with strong cash positions and minimal debt
• Prioritise businesses selling essential goods with inelastic demand
• Consider some allocation to Treasury bonds as a hedge
• Look for companies with pricing power that can maintain margins even in challenging environments

The bottom line

While falling prices might sound appealing at first glance, deflation presents serious economic challenges that can affect everyone from homeowners to business owners to workers. Understanding these dynamics helps explain why economists and policymakers go to such lengths to maintain a small but positive inflation rate.

Rather than hoping for prices to fall, most experts suggest that the healthiest economy is one with stable, low inflation, allowing for gradual price increases while avoiding the deflation trap that can be so difficult to escape.

‍